Portfolio Valuations: Why It Matters for Private Capital Investors

In the dynamic world of the Private Capital industry, Portfolio Valuation is a critical process for accurate performance reporting and evaluation.  However, unlike publicly traded stocks with readily available market data, valuing private investments requires more prudence, independence, and objectivity. For Private Equity and Venture Capital funds, ensuring accurate investment valuations is essential for informed decision-making, risk mitigation, and achieving long-term financial objectives.

The Perils of Inaccurate Valuations

Inaccurate valuations paint an incomplete picture of portfolio performance. Investors may be misled into believing their portfolio is performing better or worse than reality. This can lead to poor investment decisions, such as allocating additional capital to underperforming assets or missing out on lucrative opportunities. During the dotcom bubble, many online and tech companies faced bankruptcy and liquidation, such as Pets.co., Webvan, 360Networks, Boo.com, eToys, and others. These companies were given high valuations, leading to rapidly rising share prices driven by strong demand. The bubble eventually burst, resulting in a market crash. Numerous tech and internet firms that went public during this period were significantly overvalued due to high demand and a lack of reliable valuation methods. Their valuations were inflated with excessive multipliers, resulting in overly optimistic and unrealistic numbers. Analysts focused on metrics like website traffic instead of fundamental analysis and revenue potential, leading to inflated valuations. 

An inaccurate valuation obscures the true risk profile of the portfolio. Investors may unknowingly expose themselves to excessive risk or underestimate the potential downside of an investment. This can jeopardize the overall portfolio’s health and potentially lead to significant financial losses, impacting all aspects of long-term success. On November 9, 2022, FTX filed for bankruptcy, while crypto exchange was growing exponentially in valuation. Various venture capital funds invested around $1.8 Billion in the venture which raised its valuation to $32 Billion in January 2022. On November 6, 2022, Binance announced that it would sell its entire position in FTT tokens — roughly 23 million FTT tokens valued at about $529 million resulting in a collapse of FTX. According to Forbes, FTX’s investors’ losses are limited to $1.8 billion. However, their paper losses are much, much higher. If any of these investors had cashed out in January 2022, when FTX peaked at the $32 billion valuation, they’d be tens or even hundreds of millions dollars richer.  

Private Capital firms are obligated to report portfolio valuations to their Limited Partners (LPs). Inaccurate valuations can lead to misleading financial statements and a breach of trust with investors. This can damage the firm’s reputation and potentially lead to regulatory scrutiny, impacting compliance across the financial reporting of the fund. A prominent venture capital firm, faced scrutiny in 2019 for allegedly inflating the valuations of its portfolio companies. This implied misleading performance reporting for investors and potentially caused them to overestimate the value of their investments. Such allegations could have potentially damaged VC’s reputation and highlight the potential risks of inaccurate valuations in the private capital industry.

During exits like mergers, acquisitions, or secondary sales, an inaccurate valuation can significantly impact the negotiated price. Investors may end up accepting lower-than-fair value offers or missing opportunities to maximize returns on their investments in deals. The market has not been favorable to those investors as well who have waited to reap more returns on overvalued investments. An example of losing an opportunity to exit an investment is WeWork. It was valued at $47 billion in January 2019 after Softbank led a $1 billion round, totaling its investment to $10 billion in WeWork. After filing for IPO in August 2019, its filing showed huge losses of $1.9 billion on $1.8 billion revenue in 2018. In May 2020, Son – SoftBank’s CEO, who had invested over $10 billion in WeWork, said he was “foolish” for the firm’s investments, and valued WeWork at $2.9 billion as per a CNBC news story. In November 2023, WeWork filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy and its stock fell to 84 cents a share, giving it a $44.5 million market capitalization.

IFRS and Private Capital Investments

The International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) provide a framework for accounting and financial reporting.  While primarily focused on publicly traded companies, IFRS  offers guidance relevant to private capital investments under certain circumstances. Below are some of the considerations: 

• IFRS 13, ‘Fair Value Measurement,’ emphasizes the importance of determining the fair value of financial assets and liabilities. While not directly mandating specific valuation methodologies for private companies, IFRS 13 outlines a fair value hierarchy that prioritizes using market data when available in business valuation.

• IFRS acknowledges the inherent subjectivity involved in private company valuations. Standards like IFRS 9, ‘Financial Instruments: Disclosures,’ permit the use of reasonable judgments and significant assumptions when market data is limited. However, the standard requires comprehensive disclosure of these judgments to ensure transparency across investment valuations.

• IFRS 9, ‘Financial Instrument,’ inculcates that all kinds of equity valuation should be at fair value as it provides the soundness of accurate equity valuation.

• IFRS principles emphasize prioritizing economic substance over legal form. This means the valuation process should reflect the underlying economic reality of the investment, not just its contractual terms, impacting all aspects of business valuation.

• IFRS mandates comprehensive disclosure of information regarding significant investment holdings. This includes details on valuation techniques used, key valuation assumptions, and any significant uncertainties associated with the valuation, ensuring transparency in business valuation.

Best Practices for Accurate Private Capital Valuations

While IFRS provides a framework, investors in Private Equity and Venture Capital can adopt additional best practices to enhance portfolio valuation accuracy:

1. Third-Party Opinion: Incorporating third-party portfolio valuation into your investment process offers significant advantages.  Mitigating conflicts of interest, enhancing objectivity, and leveraging specialized expertise all contribute to achieving accurate and transparent portfolio valuations.
2. Engaging Qualified Professionals: Partnering with valuation professionals with experience in the Private Equity and Venture Capital industry can ensure the application of appropriate methodologies and a comprehensive understanding of market trends for accurate business valuations.
3. Maintaining Detailed Records: Maintaining meticulous financial records for portfolio companies allows for a more accurate assessment of past performance and facilitates reliable future projections.
4. Regular Portfolio Review: Conducting periodic portfolio valuations, not just at year-end, allows for timely identification of any discrepancies or changes in market conditions that may impact valuation. 
5. Stress Testing: Stress testing the portfolio against various economic scenarios can help investors understand the potential impact of unforeseen events on valuations and overall portfolio risk. 

Ready to ensure your portfolio is valued accurately based on global best practices? Contact our team of experienced professionals from the Private Equity and Venture Capital industry for a complimentary consultation on portfolio valuations.

Schedule a call: https://calendly.com/p01consulting/30min?month=2023-03